Just Knock It Down: demolish St. Paul's first, decide later
The former St. Paul's School main building on Stewart Avenue in Garden City, New York, has stood vacant since the school closed in 1991. The Village bought the campus in 1993. Since then it has commissioned study after study, and estimates for reuse have climbed from about $18 million in 1994 to roughly $80 million in 2026. This independent citizen site argues that the Village should demolish the building first, clear the site, and decide the land's future afterward.
What this site covers
The benefits of demolishing first. Why clearing the site before choosing a use is the better order. What the building has cost and what the options would cost. A timeline of every referendum, poll, study and board vote. Common preservation arguments and the record that answers them. How to contact the Village Board of Trustees. A full list of sources.
This is an independent citizen site. It is not affiliated with the Village of Garden City.